Poking around for vintage Plymouth emblems I found this one with nice red type that would go nicely with a contrasting smooth script typeface for "creamery".
Keeping it bold and simple we developed a monogram with the M and the C from Magnolia Creamery. Along with the emblem type and the "creamy" script type we get a mark that has vintage look with a modern feel.
Below you will see some different configurations of all the elements mentioned above. Try not to think of this as picking one or the other, you could like a part of one and not part of another.